NZIOB congratulates the winners of the 2020 NZ Building Industry Awards
The New Zealand Institute of Building (NZIOB) announced the winners of the 2020 New Zealand Building Industry Awards on Friday, 30 October. Due to the uncertainty created by COVID-19, this year’s awards event was held across three venues: in Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch. It was also live-streamed which enabled family and friends to watch the event online.
NZIOB Chief Executive Malcolm Fleming said, “That we received a record number of entries this year, while growing our total ‘in-person’ attendance numbers by over 30%, reflects a confident industry. The key takeaways from reviewing this year’s entries, included: Building Information Modelling (BIM), which is a technology that the NZIOB has been a leading promoter of, has become a standard tool for designing and delivering commercial construction projects; there is no shortage of creativity being applied on our country’s building sites; and the construction industry provides incredible opportunities for our young people. As an example of the latter, this year’s Young Achiever and our Supreme Award winner, at under 30 and 35 years of age respectively, are both responsible for delivering $100M + construction projects.”
The GIB® Supreme Award was, this year, won by James Reed from Dominion Constructors for managing the University of Auckland’s new Waiparuru Hall, a hall of residence for school leavers with 786 bedrooms.
The project provided numerous challenges over the 36-month build – design, logistics and programme being key concerns. Housing 786 school leaver’s from around the country meant there was no flexibility on the opening date. The site meant delivery management was a key component. Deliveries had to be done just-in-time as there was no standby on the street. James pushed for prefab toilet pods, an innovative approach that improved quality, but which required careful planning, given the lack of storage space on-site.
The Judges noted that this project started as a hard tender then converted to an Early Contractor Involvement (ECI). James embraced technology, using BIM and other new technologies where possible to simplify and enhance the build process.
They said, James was an integral part of the research behind the builder-led proposal to supply the bathrooms as modular toilet pods, as opposed to a traditional bathroom fit-out method as originally designed, as he was with the proposal to change the foundation work to a raft design. Both proposals were accepted by the client, who saw James as the main factor in delivering an exceptional result. James demonstrated excellent leadership skills, promoting innovative solutions and utilising an array of technologies that enhanced the project delivery.
This year the judges awarded the BCITO Young Achievers Award to Rhys McKenzie from Hawkins.
Rhys began in construction working as a labourer on the Northland Region Corrections Facility (NRCF) project for Arrow. He impressed his manager, who encouraged him to undertake a construction cadetship.
On finishing his cadetship, he completed a Diploma in Construction Management at Unitec and was a finalist in the NZIOB Awards for managing the Auckland Prison Exercise Yard Modifications project. He was made Construction Project Manager at 24 years of age, returning to Northland to run a $27m NRCF project.
Rhys has subsequently delivered several Corrections projects, leading site teams on complex projects, and now runs a $100m+ project for Hawkins.
The Judges noted Rhys’ enthusiasm, attention to detail, willingness to work hard and take advantage of opportunities offered. They said he has the qualities necessary to build on the success he has achieved to date in the future and is an exceptional candidate for the Young Achiever Award.
This year the Judges identified a Category Winner for each of the Cost-band Awards, the winners of these Awards are:
- Resene: Projects under $5M Award
Excellence & Category Winner: Kane Blank, Aspec Construction Limited
Project: St Peter’s Chapel, Auckland
- NZIOB Charitable Trust: Projects $5M-$10 Award
Highly Commended & Category Winner: Nigel Bannan, Cook Brothers Construction
Project: Dark Sky Project, Takapō (Tekapo)
- Steel Construction NZ: Projects $10M-$20M Award
Excellence & Category Winner: Craig Harris, Naylor Love Canterbury
Project: New World Durham Street, Christchurch
- Carters: Projects $20M-$35M Award
Excellence & Category Winner: James Sutherland, CMP Construction
Project: Life Apartments, 42 Liverpool Street, Auckland
- GIB®: Projects $35M-$100M Award
Excellence & Category Winner: Carl Bohnen, Naylor Love Wellington
Project: Wellington Girls’ East College Major Redevelopment, Wellington
- BBD: Projects over $100M Award
Excellence & Category Winner: James Reed, Dominion Constructors Ltd
Project: University of Auckland, Waiparuru Hall, Auckland
The James Hardie Innovation Award, recognising innovation in the industry demonstrated within a project or through an innovative new product or procedure, was won by Baran Balaban from Spiral Drillers Civil Limited.
Spiral Drillers ‘Team Workshop’ develops project-specific construction tools and equipment by using an innovative problem-solving approach. 'Team Workshop' is a group of Spiral Drillers Civil employees from different backgrounds including operators, engineers, mechanics and managers.
While each innovation is different, the aim is the same, to substitute labour-intensive work with speciality innovations and equipment.
Each innovation helps improve safety, productivity and quality of the specific task. When 'Team Workshop' is confronted with an on-site obstacle, it responds by designing and constructing specialised equipment to do the job.
The Judges noted that these innovations produced measurable production savings and improved health and safety results by removing difficult manual tasks. These innovations reduce hazards and save time and money, resulting in a ‘win-win’ for all the stakeholders on the job.
The Dahua Technology Consultants Award was this year, awarded to Kelly Haora from Griffiths & Associates Ltd for the Otangarie Papakainga Project in Whangarei. This award recognises outstanding performance of design consultants (architects, engineers, quantity surveyors or project managers) who have contributed to the design, documentation and delivery stages of a successful project.
The Otangarie Papakainga project was undertaken for a local Māori social services trust and involved providing up to six two-bedroomed units to provide transitional housing for whanau in need. This project was the first of its type in Tai Tokerau and Otangarie Papakainga are planning to undertake more of these projects over the next 12-18 months.
The project’s scope included working with the client and funders, the preparation of business plans, timelines, cash flows and risk. Following the approval of the business case, Griffiths & Associates were engaged as Project Managers and Quantity Surveyors reporting to the client’s Chief Executive. The project sought a design proposal that followed traditional Maori village design principles, being considerations that saw the Resource Consent and Building Consent applications sitting well outside what are deemed to be permitted activities. These aspects along with the requirement to amalgamate two adjoining sites were elements that a typical project manager would not be required to deal with; rather, they would be given to a separate consultant to work through.
Additional challenges involved site security in an area that was accessible to the general public and difficult to secure and having to work within a tight budget with funders who expected work to be completed to an exacting standard.
Project Manager Kelly Haora overcame the challenges. He also undertook a comprehensive and long-running process of engagement with the Northland District Council, the result of which is the Council provided the necessary consents for Otangarei Papakainga. Even more impressively, this created opportunities for other Iwi projects to seek consents for projects with similar design principles in Northland. Kelly’s determination was the key to achieving an excellent outcome for his client.
The Hays Interdisciplinary Collaboration Award, recognising exceptional examples of collaborative partnerships between consultants and contractor, was won by Neville McAnnalley, Leighs Construction; Neville Clarke, WSP Opus; James Bones, Beca; Patrick Dowle, Department of Corrections; and Brett Zeiler, White Construction for the Mt Eden Corrections Facility (MECF), Auckland.
This project formed part of the Department of Correction’s ‘Capacity Programme’ within the largest remand prison in the country. MECF has a high volume of prisoner movements, releases and visits.
The 7,770m2 multi-storey accommodation block is in the middle of the MECF and accommodates 245 prisoners. Building a team capable of delivering a project of this scale and complexity was always going to be challenging. Taking a historic design, changing the delivery architect and going on to construct the works provided additional challenges.
The Judges said that the Department of Corrections was committed to collaboration, creating a site office for the client representative, consultants, and contractor to co-habit during the construction of the project. This collaboration helped ensure a well-executed project.
The Site Safety & CHASNZ Safety Excellent Award, which celebrates a new product or process that promotes construction safety, was this year awarded to Teck Khing Yong and Daniel Chang Liu of Livefirm Construction (North Island) Limited for their Livefirm Mitre Saw Dust Control Station.
The Livefirm Mitre Saw Dust Control Station addresses dust extraction by collecting more than 90 per cent of dust produced. As a result, it significantly reduces the dust inhalation hazard, thereby providing significant health benefits. Teck Khing Yong and Daniel Chang Liu have designed an innovative, mobile, cyclone and bucket system that uses a cyclone effect to trap dust. While the primary benefit is reducing dust inhalation, it also reduces cleaning time and maintenance costs. Other advantages include reduced energy consumption.
The Judges said this innovation provides multiple health and safety benefits, resulting in an enhanced working environment.
Simon Barnes FNZIOB, the Convenor of the New Zealand Building Awards Judging Panel said, “This year we have seen an increased number of entries in each category. Once again, the calibre of the people being judged by their peers is outstanding. I thank the judges for providing their time, enthusiasm and expertise in selecting the winners of this year’s awards.
“The NZIOB recognises the support the finalists and winners have received from their companies, teams and families, which has enabled them to deliver world-class construction projects to their clients and the wider community.”
About the New Zealand Building Industry Awards
Established in 1994, the NZIOB’s annual awards programme are sponsored by GIB®. From the outset, the awards have celebrated and recognised an individuals’ professional excellence in the building and construction process of a recently completed project, as opposed to recognising and awarding the project or completed structure.
The awards are open to any individual or team in the Built Environment whose personal attributes have contributed to the success of a project and who demonstrate individual or team excellence in:
- Management methods and technique.
- Degree of project complexities.
- Any innovations developed during construction process.
- Relationship with the client, architect, authorities, community and work force (employees, suppliers, subcontractors, etc.).
- Delivery of quality outcome of the completed project.
- Project completion on time and within budget.
Simon Barnes is the Convener of Judging. Simon is a Quantity Surveyor with 40 years’ experience across a wide range of commercial, residential, industrial and retail developments.
Judging is done in two stages over a two-month period by a judging panel made up of experienced people from a cross-section of the New Zealand construction industry.